Cross-posted on Readerling
I requested this from NetGalley
because I have a shine for the Black Plague, and young adult novels about ridiculously awful social and bacteriological devastation appeal to me in the abstract. Unfortunately for this reader, it wasn't really about bubonic plague. This book also skews younger than the young adult label implies, really more for the 10-14 demographic than late high school or slumming adults. There's been a lot of fracture in the age distinctions for novels in the past however long - apparently there is a category called New Adult
these days? - but I think that sometimes those distinctions can be fruitful. Or if not fruitful, than useful for readers to determine interest level.
[b:Peregrine Harker & The Black Death|17158800|Peregrine Harker & The Black Death|Luke Hollands|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1356039133s/17158800.jpg|23582396] absolutely screams to me reluctant boy reader
, with its parentless boy detective type first-person narrator who is a cross between the pre-radioactive-spider-bitten Peter Parker and Tin Tin. He is hauled in by a superior at the newspaper and ordered to stop going off on wild tangents, and then immediately goes off on a wild tangent that gets him knocked on the head and embroiled in a Scooby Doo style mystery. There's some mild family angst, but everybody is too busy running around and avoiding being buried alive and the like to really delve into melodrama.
Everything is extremely action-driven, and moves fairly breathlessly around an almost overdone Victorian England. The prose is very pip pip cheerio old bean bloke lorry loo
, and it took me a while to determine that this wasn't meant to be funning on British prose style, but straight up. Or maybe it is funning after all, but it is very over the top in its Britishiosity. I didn't exactly like this, but I think for the demographic who should be reading this, it would be fun and novel.
I'm going to admit here I didn't finish [b:Peregrine Harker & The Black Death|17158800|Peregrine Harker & The Black Death|Luke Hollands|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1356039133s/17158800.jpg|23582396]. A book aimed at boys who don't like to read and therefore gives them scads and scads of action to the detriment of anything else a novel might provide isn't really my bag. I think I'm sounding a little bitter here, but I don't mean to go that way. Stylized action vehicles are completely valid, especially if you're trying to sucker some snot-nosed brat into reading instead of Minecraft. I think my 9 year old, who is an unreluctant boy reader, would probably enjoy this as action fluff. Young people who are afraid that books might have girl cooties all over them will likely enjoy this too. This is mostly cootie-free.
But I don't think somewhat mindless action vehicles are ultimately going to turn the reluctant reader into an avid one, because there's not a lot of here here. I don't believe that reading is ennobling, and I don't think it has to be didactic or educational to be worthwhile. The things that make reading rewarding, or differently rewarding than building Legos or Mariocart - finely drawn (or even exaggerated) emotional states, engaging or challenging prose, thoughtful plotting, any kind of character study - are not in evidence here. And not that this one novel has to adhere to my cranky old standards or solve all the issues I have with how reading fits into other media, gendered divisions in marketing, and whatnot. A perfectly slap-happy read for someone other than me.